Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
Editorial: Don't confuse charter schools with voucher schools
Editorial: Don't confuse charter schools with voucher schools

Editorial: Don't confuse charter schools with voucher schools

  • 0

Every charter school in Wisconsin is a public school.

The many Democrats running for governor should memorize this fact, because some of them are getting it wrong.

Charter schools should not be confused with voucher schools, which are mostly private religious schools that receive public money for lower-income students to attend.

The two are very different.

Former state Rep. Kelda Roys, one of eight Democrats seeking her party’s nomination for governor Aug. 14, said in a recent interview she opposes “private charters.”

“We need to stop privatization because that money comes right off the top and it’s only what’s left over after the charters have gotten their money that goes to our public schools,” Roys told WORT-FM (89.9) in Madison. “That’s wrong.”

Actually, Roys is wrong.

As Politifact Wisconsin noted in an analysis of her interview last week, all charter schools in Wisconsin are public schools.

“Every charter school is entirely publicly funded, open to any student, and free to any student,” the fact-checking journalism website noted.

Of 234 charter schools in Wisconsin, the vast majority — 211 — are operated within public school districts. Only 23 are “independent” charters, meaning they have the freedom to do what they want, outside the control of local school boards.

But even those are public schools. And they are authorized by public entities, such as the city of Milwaukee or UW-Milwaukee. Nonprofits run these few schools under contract and must meet performance targets to continue to operate.

Roys faulted fellow Democratic candidate for governor Tony Evers for securing a large federal grant for charter schools in Wisconsin. Evers is the state superintendent of public instruction, overseeing Wisconsin’s more than 400 school districts.

Evers should be credited, not criticized, for collecting $95 million in federal money for public charter schools last year to encourage innovation and improvement in public schools.

Roys objects to the small number of public charter schools that are allowed to operate independently of local school boards. But innovation sometimes requires the ability to try new things outside the bounds of the status quo.

Evers’ position makes the most sense — and brings in more federal money — for the cause of public education in Wisconsin.

The Nuestro Mundo charter school in Madison, for example, has helped hundreds of children — some native Spanish speakers, others English speakers with no Spanish skills — become fluent in both languages. And now the school’s “dual language immersion” model has expanded to other Madison public schools.

Moreover, some of the federal money Evers’ DPI is distributing to charter schools this year will help economically disadvantaged students get off to strong starts at One City Senior Preschool, a charter started by Kaleem Caire, former CEO of the Urban League of Greater Madison.

Democrats who hope to become governor this fall should embrace the cause of public charter schools, rather than pretending they privatize education.

Catch the latest in Opinion

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Badger Sports

Breaking News