Skip to main contentSkip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
top story

Democrats look for 2 more Wisconsin special elections wins

  • 0
Ann Groves Lloyd

Assembly candidate Ann Groves Lloyd speaks to volunteers at the Columbia County Democratic Party office in downtown Portage in April.

The winners of Wisconsin’s special legislative elections this week may never see a hearing or floor session in Madison. But the money and effort being spent to capture the two open seats underscore how important they’ve become in shaping perceptions of party strength heading to November.

Democrats are counting on victories to build on two big wins earlier this year and reinforce a “blue wave” looming for this fall’s elections. Republicans would love to grab the seats as evidence momentum is shifting.

“I don’t care if it’s an anti-Trump sentiment or if it’s an anti-Republican sentiment or if it’s just dissatisfaction with a party that’s been in control for eight years,” Senate Minority Leader Jennifer Shilling said. “We need to capitalize on it.”

The seats opened up when Gov. Scott Walker appointed the Republican incumbents to his administration.

Walker called special elections to fill the spots only after a judge ordered him to schedule them, leading Democrats to charge that the governor fears the GOP will lose the seats.

Democrat Ann Groves Lloyd meets Republican Jon Plumer in south-central Wisconsin’s 42nd Assembly District. Meanwhile, Democrat Caleb Frostman faces Republican state Rep. Andre Jacque in northeastern Wisconsin’s 1st Senate District.

Both districts have trended Republican over the past 20 years. But Democrats already won a special election for a Senate seat in a conservative western district this year and saw a liberal candidate easily beat a conservative in a nonpartisan Supreme Court race. With 42 legislative seats nationwide flipping to Democrats since President Donald Trump took office, outside groups are spending heavily on the races.

The elections can’t change the balance of power in either chamber. Republicans hold a 63-35 majority in the Assembly and an 18-14 advantage in the Senate. The winners probably won’t vote on anything — the Legislature isn’t expected to return to Madison until its next two-year session begins in January — before they have to run again in November.

The 42nd Assembly District is rural and has been in Republican hands for most of the past 20-plus years. Democrats broke that grip in 2008, when Fred Clark rode a Democratic wave into office.

But Clark was defeated after Republicans redrew the district boundaries in 2011.

Lloyd retired from her job as a UW-Madison student adviser on June 1. She has portrayed herself in an ad as a farmer, saying she grew up on her family’s Columbia County farm. Republicans say the ad is misleading since her family now rents out the land.

Plumer, a karate school owner, had to explain last week his 1997 citation for disorderly conduct stemming from a family dispute. His then-teenage daughter accused him of pushing her out of the house and pushing her mother down during an argument.

Plumer denied pushing either of them, and his daughter said last week she lied about the incident.

Lloyd has outraised Plumer, $302,157 to $187,690.

The 1st Senate District stretches from the Fox Cities to the tip of the Door Peninsula and has trended solidly red since at least 1995.

Jacque is one of the most conservative members of the state Assembly. A group of powerful Assembly Republicans endorsed his primary opponent, but coalesced around Jacque after he won the contest.

Frostman quit his job as Door County Economic Development Corp. executive director to campaign full-time. He said in an interview he feels like the underdog, even though his campaign has raised $188,660 this year, compared with Jacque’s $79,000.

Outside groups are pouring money into the Senate race. According to government watchdog group Wisconsin Democracy Campaign, the Wisconsin League of Conservation Voters’ political action committee is shelling out about $172,900 on staff and ads to support Frostman. Former U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder’s group, the National Democratic Redistricting Committee, is spending $35,000 on brochures and staff to help him as well.

The Wisconsin Alliance for Reform has spent $160,000 to produce and air television ads supporting Jacque.

Outside groups have spent more than $110,000 in the 42nd. For Our Future is spending about $16,700 on staff and brochures to support Lloyd, and Holder’s group is spending another $15,000 on online advertising for her. The Wisconsin Realtors Political Fund is spending about $8,300 on ads and calls to support Plumer.

The Jobs First Coalition has spent an estimated $70,000 to produce and air radio ads supporting Plumer.

All four candidates have registered to run again in November.


Get Government & Politics updates in your inbox!

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Badger Sports

Breaking News