Skip to main content
You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.
DNR to withhold data on PFAS in wastewater; agreement with WMC allows sampling to continue
topical alert
Environment | Chemical Testing

DNR to withhold data on PFAS in wastewater; agreement with WMC allows sampling to continue

  • 0
Nine Springs Wastewater Treatment Plant (copy)

The Nine Springs Wastewater Treatment Plant is seen in Madison. The Department of Natural Resources will withhold data on hazardous unregulated chemicals in wastewater as part of an agreement with Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce. 

Wisconsin environmental regulators have agreed to withhold data on hazardous chemicals in wastewater while the courts decide whether state law allows testing for yet-unregulated compounds known as PFAS.

Under an agreement with the state’s largest business group, the Department of Natural Resources can continue sampling water from industrial and municipal treatment plants for the “forever chemicals” but will not release the results to the public.

The agreement, filed Tuesday in Jefferson County Circuit Court, replaces a judge’s temporary restraining order issued last week in the lawsuit brought by Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce.

It bars the DNR from releasing any test results collected since April 1 that are tied to a facility, address or county, though the agency can publish anonymized data.

WMC has sought to block the DNR from testing for PFAS, a class of human-made chemicals that have been shown to cause cancer and other illnesses but are not currently regulated by state code.

The Biden administration's work to sell its more than $2 trillion infrastructure plan is underway and it's facing opposition from within its own party.Sen. Joe Manchin told a West Virginia radio host Monday that he won't support the plan if the corporate tax rate is raised from 21 to 28 percent as proposed. He said several of his Democratic colleagues agree with him.The plan won't pass the Senate without the support of every Democratic senator, but the White House says it isn't concerned."Some will believe that the package we proposed is too small. Some will believe it's too big. And we're happy to have discussions with members who have both points of view," said White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki. "We're hopeful that others will come forward with ideas that are as bold and innovative and will help do the same type of work for American workers in our economy."GOP leader Mitch McConnell has already said the plan won't get a single Republican vote, but the administration says it remains hopeful for a bipartisan deal.Already, the five cabinet members tasked with outreach have had conversations with 56 lawmakers split evenly among Democrats and Republicans.The president plans to invite lawmakers from both parties to the Oval Office once they return from recess. 

Because they do not break down naturally, PFAS accumulate in animal and human tissue and can be spread on farm fields in sludge from sewage treatment plants. PFAS have contaminated soil and groundwater at sites across the state, including Madison, Marinette and La Crosse.

The DNR is in the process of developing water standards for two PFAS compounds, and the Department of Health Services has recommended limits for 16 more. As part of the rule-making process, those standards will require approval from the Republican-led Legislature.

If the standards are adopted, facilities would have to remove the compounds from wastewater, which the DNR has estimated will cost tens of millions of dollars statewide. In the lawsuit, WMC argues the agency does not have the statutory authority to test for contaminants when there are no standards in place.

According to the complaint, the sampling program is related to the PFAS rule-making process, though the DNR intends to test for more than 30 PFAS compounds — far beyond the approved scope for the rule-making process.

WMC says by releasing the results, the DNR is “risking significant reputational harm to the businesses” that could be stigmatized as polluters even though they are in compliance with their discharge permits.

In February, WMC and an Oconomowoc dry cleaner sued the DNR in Waukesha County Circuit Court, seeking to block DNR’s ability to require cleanup of PFAS.

State law gives the DNR authority to regulate the discharge of hazardous substances, though there is no definitive list of those substances, which can include toxic chemicals as well as otherwise innocuous substances like milk in certain circumstances.

In that case, WMC argues the DNR should be required to go through the 30-month rule-making process to establish a list of what substances qualify as hazardous.


Be the first to know

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Badger Sports

Breaking News