Scales of Justice

A Waunakee real estate developer who bilked investors out of nearly $10 million has been sentenced to seven years in federal prison.

Patrick O’Connor, 61, was sentenced by U.S. District Judge William Conley in federal court in Madison on Tuesday. He pleaded guilty in April to charges of wire fraud and money laundering.

The U.S. Attorney’s Office said O’Connor conducted a Ponzi scheme as part of the fraud, sending money to investors as proof they were making money from their investing in Madison Financial Services, a company he set up in 2011, and continued to bilk investors into 2018.

“In total, O’Connor convinced six investors to invest over $12 million with him,” U.S. Attorney Scott Blader said in a statement. “The total loss to the investors, once the fraud scheme was revealed, was $9,686,848.”

O’Connor misrepresented the operation to the investors, telling them money invested in Madison Financial Services would be put into a TradeStation online brokerage account.

“He said he would use the account to actively trade purchased securities,” the release said. “He projected an average annual return on the investment of 2% a month, or 24% annually.”

O’Connor instead took a large part of the invested money and paid for personal expenses, including for his real estate business, and to repay other investors.

Register for more free articles
Stay logged in to skip the surveys

The case against him started in October 2017 when an IRS investigator paid a visit to O’Connor.

He was asked about a $500,000 check from an investor that only had $300,000 transferred into O’Connor’s TradeStation account.

“Records showed he used the remaining $200,000 to pay off a real estate loan and for various personal expenses, but he lied to the investigator and said the investor also was investing in his real estate company, and any remaining money used for his personal expenses came from a fee charged to the client,” the release said.

At sentencing, Conley said the Ponzi scheme was “calculated and predatory” and said the total amount of money stolen was “staggering.”

Conley said O’Connor was motivated by pride, hubris and greed, adding his decision to take more money from investors after the investigation started was “morally bankrupt.”

Capital W: Plug in to Wisconsin politics

Subscribe to our Politics email!

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.