Skip to main contentSkip to main content
You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.
Attorneys allowed to withdraw from double homicide case; new counsel to be appointed
alert top story

Attorneys allowed to withdraw from double homicide case; new counsel to be appointed

The attorneys for a man accused of shooting a Madison doctor and her husband to death last year were allowed to withdraw from the man’s case after a brief hearing Friday.

Andrew Martinez and Jeremiah Meyer-O’Day told Dane County Circuit Judge Ellen Berz that a conflict had come up in their representation of Khari O. Sanford, 19, of Madison, who is charged in the March 30, 2020, fatal shooting of Dr. Beth Potter and her husband, Robin Carre.

The couple was found in the UW-Madison Arboretum the next morning by a jogger. Sanford was the boyfriend of the couple’s daughter. A criminal complaint detailed tensions that had arisen in the Potter-Carre household between Sanford, the couple’s daughter and the couple.

At a hearing Friday, Martinez told Berz the conflict was not due to the attorneys’ representation of another client, but instead due to something Sanford did or said, which Martinez and Meyer-O’Day did not specify. Meyer-O’Day said a second reason had also arisen for withdrawal from the case — Sanford had filed a complaint against his attorneys with the state Office of Lawyer Regulation.

Those complaints are confidential unless acted upon by a referee or the state Supreme Court.

Khari Sanford


Martinez said he and Meyer-O’Day were not aware of the OLR complaint at the time they initially asked to withdraw from Sanford’s case.

Nevertheless, Sanford said in court Friday that he still wanted Martinez and Meyer-O’Day to continue as his attorneys, which he had also said during a hearing on Tuesday. But based on the fact of the OLR complaint and the prior conflict, Berz agreed to allow Martinez and Meyer-O’Day to withdraw.

Martinez said he has already been in contact with the state Public Defender’s Office to let it know it may have to appoint new counsel for Sanford.

But with a trial set for October and Berz steadfast about keeping the trial date, it may be a challenge to find an attorney qualified to handle a first-degree intentional homicide case who has a schedule open enough to absorb the large file that accompanies Sanford’s case in time to represent him at a trial in October.

Sanford’s co-defendant, Ali’jah Larrue, 19, is scheduled to enter a guilty or no contest plea on May 25 to a yet-unspecified charge under a plea agreement reached with prosecutors. Currently, he is charged with being a party to two counts of first-degree intentional homicide.

Martinez had said at the time trial dates were set for Sanford that they may ultimately be unnecessary because talks on Sanford’s behalf were ongoing with prosecutors.

Sign up for our Crime & Courts newsletter

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Badger Sports

Breaking News