Judge Doyle Square podium rendering

The "podium," seen in this rendering of one possible design for the structure, was at the heart of a lawsuit filed by the Judge Doyle Square developer against the city of Madison.

The developer of the Judge Doyle Square development in Downtown Madison has dropped a federal lawsuit over the city’s decision to finance some private portions of the project.

Beitler Real Estate Services of Chicago dismissed the lawsuit Wednesday in U.S. District Court in Illinois.

Beitler had sued the city in June over the City Council’s decision to appropriate $11 million to construct first-floor retail, two floors of private parking and a structural slab — collectively known as the “podium” — in the massive redevelopment of the two blocks containing the Madison Municipal Building and the Government East parking garage.

In a statement, Madison City Attorney Michael May called Beitler’s decision to dismiss the lawsuit “a necessary first step” toward having productive discussions about the future of the development.

“With the lawsuit out of the way the city hopes to renew discussions with Beitler on how to modify the existing development agreement so that the project may proceed,” he said.

Judge Doyle Square (copy) (copy)

Construction on an underground public parking garage at Judge Doyle Square is well underway. 

Thanks for visiting our newly updated site!
njoy unlimited articles FREE for a limited time by signing up or logging in. No credit card required.

He declined further comment.

In the dismissed lawsuit, Beitler alleged that the city had “unilaterally seized” the private portions of the development assigned to Beitler.

The council approved the $11 million appropriation after Beitler informed the city that it could not pursue those private portions of the development unless the city financed it or allowed Beitler to lease parking spaces in the public garage so it could avoid the cost of constructing private parking.

The developer blamed rising construction costs for its inability to obtain financing.

The 560-stall, underground public parking garage is under construction on the block holding the Madison Municipal Building, and the podium will go on top of it. Beitler also intends to build nine floors of apartments above that.

Following the construction of the new parking garage, demolition of the Government East garage is scheduled to begin, and Beitler would then construct two towers containing apartments and a hotel serving Monona Terrace.

Capital W: Plug in to Wisconsin politics

Subscribe to our Politics email!

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Rob Schultz has won multiple writing awards at the state and national levels and covers an array of topics for the Wisconsin State Journal in south-central and southwestern Wisconsin.