Skip to main content
You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.
Edit
Democrats say hasty legislation was the death knell of bipartisanship in state
0 Comments

Democrats say hasty legislation was the death knell of bipartisanship in state

  • 0
Capitol shocker

Rep. Peter Barca, D-Kenosha, right, continues to object while Sen. Scott Fitzgerald, R-Juneau, bangs a gavel adjourning a committee meeting on March 9, 2011, at which Republicans advanced the bill despite Democrats' absence. 

Former Sen. Mark Miller and Rep. Peter Barca tried to slow down passage of the legislation to force a compromise.

As it became evident that Republicans in the Legislature planned to rush through passage of Act 10, Democratic lawmakers, who held minorities in the Assembly and Senate, knew they had to get creative.

Their radical solution: Flee the state.

Fourteen Democratic state senators, including then-Minority Leader Mark Miller, drove across the state line to Illinois in an effort to block the vote while putting them beyond the reach of Wisconsin law enforcement, who might have brought them back by force. Assembly Minority Leader Peter Barca and his fellow Democrats in that house stayed at the Capitol to try to negotiate with Republicans.

Peter Barca

Barca

“Really, the whole goal was just to slow it down so there would have to be some consideration because (Walker’s) plan was to ram it through in just a matter of a week or two,” said Barca, who now serves as Democratic Gov. Tony Evers’ revenue secretary.

Initially proposed as a fiscal bill, Act 10 would require a vote by at least two-thirds of each chamber. To deny the quorum, Senate Democrats relocated to a hotel in northern Illinois for almost three weeks.

“We felt that we were really on the verge of a watershed moment that was going to change the direction of politics in the state of Wisconsin and nationally quite frankly,” said Miller, who retired from the Senate in January after 22 years in the Legislature.

Sen. Mark Miller

Miller

Miller recalls lawmakers meeting daily to discuss their next move, fielding calls from state, national and international media outlets and rotating laundry duties at a local laundromat.

At one point, Senate Republicans ordered police to detain the missing Democrats, but the request was deemed unenforceable.

Eventually, Republicans used a series of parliamentary maneuvers to overcome the stalemate, including removing the bill’s fiscal elements, to approve Act 10. That allowed them to vote on the bill without their Democratic colleagues present.

Back at the Capitol, the committee taking up the revised bill gave Barca — the only Democratic member present — an hour’s notice. Barca recalls being given about “three minutes” to read and digest the roughly 75-page summary. As he began proposing amendments, Republicans called for a vote.

“I think it was those kinds of things that stood out to such a degree — that they were willing to violate the rules and certainly the norms of the Legislature that we’d had for so long and really deny Wisconsin tradition,” Barca said. “Wisconsin is a state where people roll up their sleeves and try to work together or if nothing else you at least give people the respect of giving them time to fully consider what’s being offered.”

Barca and Miller both point to Act 10 as the death knell of bipartisanship in state government.

“One of the things that has really concerned me over the course of my legislative career has been the increasing divisions, not only among Republicans and Democrats, that sort of partisan division, but in the general population as a whole, and Act 10 was one of the things that pushed us over a very steep cliff in that respect,” Miller said.

— Mitchell Schmidt

Editor's note: This story is part of a series marking the 10-year anniversary of Act 10. Click here for more stories from people who experienced the historic events firsthand. 


Act 10: Full Coverage 


Watch now: The Great Divide | 10 stories about Act 10

The most seismic political story of the last decade in Wisconsin began on Feb. 7, 2011, when Republican Gov. Scott Walker informed a gathering of cabinet members of plans to unilaterally roll back the power of public sector unions in the state. He "dropped the bomb," as Walker would describe it afterward, four days later.

The audacious proposal, to be known forever after as Act 10, required public employees to pay more for pension and health insurance benefits, but also banned most subjects of collective bargaining and placed obstacles to maintaining union membership.

The proposal laid bare the state's deep, at times intensely personal, political divisions as tens of thousands of protesters descended on the Capitol. The month-long, round-the-clock occupation drew international attention, but failed to stop the bill.

A decade later, the aftershocks of one of the biggest political earthquakes in Wisconsin history continue to be felt. Taxes have been held in check, and state finances have improved. But public unions are vastly diminished and the state is more politically divided than ever.

Here are 10 stories from people who experienced the historic events firsthand.

web only
  • 0
web only
  • 0

Former Sen. Mark Miller and Rep. Peter Barca tried to slow down passage of the legislation to force a compromise.

web only
  • 0

A decade later, former Gov. Scott Walker said he views Act 10 as one of the best things he's done for the state.

web only
  • 0

Susan Cohen wondered if the Capitol dome would come crumbling down from the cacophonous vibrations during the Act 10 protests.

web only
  • 0

Dale Schultz believes the state's ability to solve people's problems was greatly diminished by Act 10.

web only
  • 0

Longtime Madison Teachers Inc. leader John Matthews explains why collective bargaining still matters.

web only
  • 0

Former Capitol Police Chief Charles Tubbs said his mission was communicating with protesters and voluntary compliance.

web only
  • 0

During the peak of the Act 10 protests, Ian's Pizza was delivering 1,200 pizzas a day to protesters. 

web only
  • 0

Sen. Joan Ballweg saw the recall elections that resulted from Act 10 as the people getting a chance to have their say.

web only
  • 0

Michele Ritt remembered her son Josef Rademacher wearing a hole in the soles of his snow boots during the protests.

web only
  • 0

Jason Stein was amazed to find himself in the midst of the No. 2 story on the New York Times home page.

0 Comments

Be the first to know

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.

Topics

News Alerts

Badger Sports

Breaking News

Crime

Politics