You are the owner of this article.
Total Wine to open April 12 at West Towne Mall

Total Wine to open April 12 at West Towne Mall

Total Wine & More

Total Wine & More will open April 12th at West Towne Mall and become Dane County's largest liquor store. The 23,146-square-foot retail space also includes wine and beer tasting stations and a classroom. The store is the third location in Wisconsin for the Maryland-based retailer.

What will be Madison's largest liquor store will open next week, add a new dimension to West Towne Mall and ratchet up the competition for beer, wine and liquor sales in Dane County.

Total Wine & More has announced that it will open its 23,146-square-foot store on April 12, just days after the neighboring Dave & Buster's opens its restaurant and arcade center. Both are in part of what for nearly five decades was home to a Sears store, which has been downsized to 56,000-square-feet to make way for the two new additions that focus not just on retail sales but tout themselves as experience-type destinations.

Total Wine & More

The Dave & Busters, located nest door to Total Wine & More, is scheduled to open Monday at West Towne Mall. The facility features a full-service restaurant, an arcade and games of skill.

Dave & Buster's, scheduled to open Monday, announced in September that it would locate its 100th store in Madison. The 31,000-square-foot facility includes a full-service restaurant, televisions to watch sporting events and a large arcade filled with simulators and games of skill.

Maryland-based Total Wine, founded in 1991 by brothers David and Robert Trone, has been more quiet with its entry into the market and only recently began talking publicly about its plans, which were unveiled in October to the city. But the store, stocked with 8,000 wines, 3,000 spirits and 2,500 types of beer, is nearly twice the size of the nearby liquor department at Woodman's Market and is expected to make a big splash when it opens.

"We're expecting many of those guests to cross shop and dine," said Tiffany Schultz, marketing director for West Towne. "They're a perfect fit. We're expecting strong traffic numbers." 

Total Wine features eight checkout lanes, a wine tasting station, a brewery area for tastings and filling growlers and a room for wine, beer and spirits classes. The room, which can also be reserved by area non-profits, is also equipped with audio and visual equipment to allow students to interact with brewers, wine makers and distillers from around the country. 

The store, with 50 employees, three-quarters of which are full time, also has the same type of liquor license as a bar, which allows it to sell more than just tastes of products.

"Our type of store is an experiential one where customers love to come and not only avail themselves to the selections, and the service and the price, but really it's about the customer experience," said Edward Cooper, Total Wine's vice president of public affairs and community relations. "This is unlike anything that Madison has ever seen. We are a destination spot and a destination retailer. We will pull a whole lot of consumers from a pretty good-sized ring."

In November 2016, Total Wine opened its first store in Wisconsin in Brookfield, although it was turned down for a class B liquor license. It opened a 24,000-square-foot store in the Milwaukee suburb of Greenfield last month, but Copper said the company will wait and study the Madison market further before deciding if it will open a store on the city's East Side or in Sun Prairie.

"It's not unusual for us to open a new store in a new market and gauge where our customers are coming from," Cooper said.

Total Wine & More

An employee works on adjusting a sign at the main entrance of Total Wine & More. The store is scheduled to open April 12.

It's unclear what impact the store may have on other retailers such as Pick 'n Save, Hy-Vee, Metcalfe's and Costco and smaller independent stores like Steve's Liquor, a Madison mainstay for nearly 70 years and now with three locations, two of which are on the West and Far West sides of the city.

Cooper, however, said the business model of Total Wine is different from other retailers, which could limit the impact, he said. Many of its customers visit only six to 12 times a year but stock up when they visit.

"I think it will be minimal," said Cooper, whose company has over 170 stores in 21 states. "The smaller independent stores have their business models and their niches and they work quite effectively."

Total Wine & More

Total Wine & More faces the Beltline where the highway intersects with Gammon Road and has prime visibility at West Towne Mall.

The opening of Total Wine and Dave & Buster's will complete months of work on the south side of the mall property that is owned not by CBL & Associates, owner of West Towne, but by Seritage Growth Properties, which bought the 18-acre Sears property from CBL in 2015.

The $17 million project has included a new parking lot and drainage system and the reconfiguration of the Sears store into three separate spaces. The Sears automotive center was not touched by the redevelopment and remains open. The openings of the two new retailers will also add a jolt to the south side of the mall property where Granite City closed its brewpub in October after 11 years while the nearby Toys R' Us store is conducting a going-out-of-business sale.

Total Wine & More

The Sears store at West Towne Mall has been downsized, which has allowed for the construction of a Dave & Busters and a Total Wine & More.

Schultz said there has been "heavy interest" in the redevelopment of the Toys R' Us property, while a new restaurant is expected to be announced for the Granite City space in the next week or so. Schultz said the restaurant will be a new entry to the Dane County dining scene and add to the vibrancy of the mall's south side. It's unclear if the new tenant will reuse the building or remove it and build new, she said.

"It's going to be a great addition to everything that’s happening here," Schultz said.

Send retail-related tips and story ideas to or call Barry Adams at 608-252-6148.



Capital W: Plug in to Wisconsin politics

Subscribe to our Politics email!

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Badger Sports

Breaking News