You are the owner of this article.
Tom Oates: Melvin Gordon's record-setting day reminiscent of The Dayne Game in 1999

Tom Oates: Melvin Gordon's record-setting day reminiscent of The Dayne Game in 1999

From the State Journal coverage of Melvin Gordon's record-setting game series

That wasn’t confetti flying at Camp Randall Stadium as darkness fell Saturday afternoon.

It was snow.

No matter, the effect was the same as it was 15 years earlier on the same field.

Just as those fluttering white towels celebrated a historic performance by Ron Dayne and the University of Wisconsin football team back in the day, the snowflakes that fell Saturday seemed tailor-made for an equally historic performance by Melvin Gordon and a comeback win for the ages by the current Badgers.

In 1999, it was Dayne breaking the NCAA career rushing record to all but sew up the Heisman Trophy and UW clinching a second consecutive Big Ten Conference title with a 41-3 victory over Iowa in the final regular-season game.

Saturday, Gordon broke the major college single-game rushing record with 408 yards to thrust himself into the upper echelon of Heisman contenders and 22nd-ranked UW gave second-year coach Gary Andersen his first signature win with a 59-24 rout of 11th-ranked Nebraska, one that put the Badgers in the driver’s seat in the Big Ten’s West Division.

That’s a lot to pack into one game. Or, in this case, two games.

“Obviously, that was such great history,” said tight end Sam Arneson, whose parents attended what came to be known as the Dayne Game in 1999. “But I think tonight has to rank up there with it.”

Indeed, it does.

The difference, of course, is that this UW team still has unfinished business. The Badgers earned themselves a one-game lead in the division, but they have games remaining with Iowa and Minnesota. And Gordon’s performance, as remarkable as it was, still won’t make him the favorite for the Heisman, though he might have turned it into a two-man race between himself and Oregon quarterback Marcus Mariota.

Yet the timing makes Saturday’s game no less important. Gordon’s stunning ability to break off long run after long run, still another stifling performance by UW’s defense, the Badgers’ refusal to flinch after falling behind 17-3 just a few plays into the second quarter, and running off 56 consecutive points against a once-beaten Nebraska team turned it into one of the more memorable games in the long history of Camp Randall.

“It was like you were in a dream, the way the game was going and then the snow and being under the lights,” Arneson said. “We scored right before ‘Jump Around’ and we were all just looking at each other like, ‘This is something special.’ It was such a special game. One I’ll never forget.”

No one was more unforgettable than Gordon, who needed only 25 carries and three quarters to rush for those 408 yards and bury the Cornhuskers. Keep in mind that Nebraska’s defense hadn’t allowed another team to rush for more than 188 yards in a game this season. Gordon blew by that mark sometime in the second quarter.

His 26-yard touchdown run on the final play of the third quarter made it 52-17 and signaled his departure. Instead of a Heisman pose, however, Gordon simply turned toward the field and bowed.

“I was just running to win,” he said.

The junior tailback took UW along for the ride with his record-setting day, prompting Andersen to call him “the best of the best” and eliciting reams of praise from teammates. Still, the comeback Gordon fueled will stand the test of time as well.

In its first 22 games under Andersen, UW had beaten only one ranked team — No. 19 Northwestern last year. And even that was somewhat tainted because it was the second of seven straight losses for the Wildcats.

But there are no asterisks attached to Nebraska, which had lost only at Michigan State and had been performing extremely well on offense, defense and special teams. The Badgers outplayed the Cornhuskers in all three phases and probably a few more, too.

“We needed a big win to make a statement,” quarterback Tanner McEvoy said. “I think we did that today. It was a great overall team win. The defense played great. We tasted adversity and we came back to win it.”

The way UW stormed back to win was the most special — and encouraging — aspect of the game. The Badgers lost three potentially demoralizing fumbles, including two by Gordon, and had an 18-yard punt to literally hand Nebraska 17 points, but never veered from their game plan or lost their resolve.

“They stayed well-grounded and fought through it,” Andersen said. “It was an amazing day to watch.”

At least as amazing as that game 15 years ago when Dayne and the Badgers made history. Quarterback Joel Stave, like many of his teammates, was just starting grade school back then and his memories of that game are a bit vague.

“I remember the papers and everyone talking about Ron Dayne and how he just absolutely blew up,” Stave said. “But I think this game and the season that Melvin’s having is right up there with anything that any running back has realistically ever done. He’s having a special year.”

Because he is, the Badgers still have a chance to do the same.

Contact Tom Oates at

or 608-252-6172.

Your guide to Camp Randall Stadium


Parking at Camp Randall Stadium


Subscribe to our BadgerBeat email!

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Badger Sports

Breaking News