Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
Edit
Dane County supervisors should do as they say, not as GOP lawmakers do
Dane County supervisors should do as they say, not as GOP lawmakers do
alert
EDITORIAL

Dane County supervisors should do as they say, not as GOP lawmakers do

  • 0

Does the Dane County Board support fair maps or not?

The public is about to find out.

The board plans to vote Thursday on a new map for its 37 voting districts. County Board supervisors will get to pick one of three maps drawn by a citizen panel. To help ensure its independence and neutrality, the 11-member panel was insulated from politics and included civic leaders such as UW-Madison political science professor Barry Burden and former Wisconsin League of Women Voters leader Andrea Kaminski.

The panel was instructed to draw the lines for Dane County’s supervisory districts based on the latest census. Each district has to have virtually the same number of people to provide voters with equal representation. The panel was told to make the districts as compact and contiguous as possible while respecting municipal boundaries.

Significantly, the panel was forbidden from drawing the lines to protect incumbents.

The Dane County Redistricting Commission did a fine job following those rules. Congratulations to its members.

This is a much better process than the Republican-run Legislature is using to draw legislative and congressional districts for Wisconsin. Top GOP leaders plan to draw similar maps to the current ones, which were surgically shaped in secret a decade ago using sophisticated mapping software and voting data to give Republicans a competitive advantage. The state’s gerrymandered maps also have created lots of safe seats for the incumbents from both parties.

Dane County’s liberal-dominated board wisely pledged years ago to do things differently and to lead by example. They created a citizen-controlled commission to draw the lines in a fair way at the local level.

Unfortunately, now that Dane County is close to accomplishing that goal, some supervisors want to undermine the process by playing the same old political games with last-minute changes.

Matt Veldran

Veldran 

Sup. Matt Veldran, who represents Madison’s Southwest Side, said he wants to “tinker with” the citizen-drawn maps. He’s worried about incumbents. Under the three maps for consideration, at least eight current board members may have to run against each other in the same districts, making reelection more difficult.

Veldran is sure to find a sympathetic ear in state Assembly Speaker Robin Vos, R-Rochester, who is busy with his Republican colleagues at the statehouse gerrymandering the lines of legislative and congressional district maps to maintain political power.

Robin Vos

Vos

But protecting incumbents and narrow political interests shouldn’t be the goal. Veldran and Vos may prefer district maps drawn by and for the politicians. But the public overwhelmingly disagrees.

Dane County voters approved a referendum calling for nonpartisan redistricting with 82% support. Similarly, 78% of Wisconsin’s counties have endorsed fair maps.

The Dane County Board on Thursday should pick one of the three maps the citizen panel created, and it should do so without delay or any changes. The board must respect the fair process it created and pledged to follow years ago.

Geske, a former state Supreme Court justice, introduces herself as one of the Wisconsin State Journal's new community editorial board members

Strong, a former Madison police lieutenant and longtime youth football coach, introduces himself as one of the Wisconsin State Journal's new community editorial board members

Schmitz, the Downtown Madison dynamo whose great-grandfather opened a store on the Capitol Square in 1898, introduces herself as one of the Wisconsin State Journal's new community

Catch the latest in Opinion

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.

Topics

News Alerts

Badger Sports

Breaking News

Crime

Politics