Commentary: Brexit enters its Meghan and Harry phase
AP

Commentary: Brexit enters its Meghan and Harry phase

  • 0
Prince Harry and Meghan Markle announced Wednesday that they were stepping back from their role as "senior members of the royal family" and would work to become financially independent. The Duke and Duchess of Sussex look at a special exhibition of art by Indigenous Canadian artist, Skawennati, in the Canada Gallery during their visit to Canada House, central London, UK on January 7, 2020.

Prince Harry and Meghan Markle announced Wednesday that they were stepping back from their role as "senior members of the royal family" and would work to become financially independent. The Duke and Duchess of Sussex look at a special exhibition of art by Indigenous Canadian artist, Skawennati, in the Canada Gallery during their visit to Canada House, central London, UK on January 7, 2020. (Daniel Leal-Olivas/PA Photos/Abaca Press/TNS)

Brexit has felt a little like Meghan and Harry's decision to stay linked to the Royal Family but "financially independent" of it. It has been hard to imagine what the new order will look like, but it's obvious that getting there will be messy. As he seeks regulatory independence from the European Union, Boris Johnson (like the royal couple) will have to make some real trade-offs.

So far it's been smooth sailing. The Brexit legislation that was a Sisyphean burden for his predecessor Theresa May for much of last year proved an easy lift Thursday with Johnson's new parliamentary majority. The House of Lords may wag a few fingers (for example, protesting the clause that gives ministers the power to tell courts where they can depart from EU case law), but it won't stand in the way of Britain's Jan. 31 departure.

The hard part is deciding priorities for the U.K.-EU trade talks that will immediately follow, because compromises carry costs. Johnson often gets his way against the odds, but the difference between what he hopes for from an EU deal and what he can realistically expect is the difference between imagining yourself as Mikaela Shiffrin tearing down a slalom slope rather than an average vacation skier.

Britain's objective is a trade agreement that covers goods and services, along with cooperation in a range of other areas. Johnson also wants flexibility to diverge from EU rules and to sign new trade deals, including with the U.S., which has a very different regulatory framework to Brussels. He has pledged that Britain won't request an extension to its transition period for exiting the EU, meaning the deal needs to be concluded this year.

On her visit to London Wednesday, European Commission President Ursula Von der Leyen smiled kindly at these demands. But beneath the soothing tones and talk of a partnership "unprecedented in scope," her message was to get real. Not only do both sides have to agree negotiating objectives, priorities and sequencing, they then have to agree the terms of a deal, the legal language and allow time for it to be implemented, including devilishly complicated new customs arrangements for Northern Ireland.

Even if both sides want very much to conclude a deal, their starting positions are far apart. Von der Leyen and her chief negotiator Michel Barnier made clear this week that there's a trade-off between market access and divergence from EU rules and standards. That, indeed, is the EU's overarching objective. The more freedom Britain has to diverge, the more Brussels will worry about a competitor on its doorstep that will use laxer regulatory standards and lower taxes to attract talent and investment. Even if the feared Singapore-on-Thames is overblown, Britain is now seen as a fierce competitor.

That makes the question of sequencing in the talks paramount. The EU won the first phase of the negotiations (for the withdrawal agreement) by insisting that the divorce terms - especially the Irish border question - were resolved before trade talks started. Britain gave away its best cards too early.

Johnson doesn't want to repeat that mistake, but with so little time, both sides will have to agree where to focus negotiations. A deal that concentrates on eliminating tariffs and quotas for goods trade only would benefit the EU (with its large goods trade surplus with Britain) more than the U.K., though it would also allow Johnson to stick to his timetable, claim a political victory and avoid having to pay more into the EU budget. Beyond that bare minimum, though, he'll probably have to concede ground on the so-called "level playing field" provisions - ensuring the U.K.'s regulations and product standards are equally tough - that are an EU obsession.

While there's much talk about a fisheries agreement - a key goal for EU members, who want access to British waters, but also for the U.K., which sells most of its fishing haul into the EU tariff-free - agriculture might be a bigger sticking point. The EU will be reluctant to remove its farming protections without knowing what kind of deals the U.K. will strike with other countries, notes Eric White, a trade law consultant at the law firm Herbert Smith Freehills. "For goods trade the tariffs are really quite small and it doesn't really stop people from importing; the regulatory barriers are much more important. But for agriculture, you have some very high duties on beef, lamb and other products (without a trade deal). Countries are very careful about giving trade concessions for agriculture because it can devastate markets," he says.

Even if these goods issues can be resolved, that still leaves services - critical to the finance-dominated U.K. economy - and many other areas. The EU wants to avoid the Swiss scenario of multiple agreements, as it makes it hard for the EU to link them if it needs leverage over its trading partner. But given time constraints and the depth of the EU-U.K. relationship, it's hard to see how the two sides have any choice but to separate out some issues, perhaps creating joint committees for adopting decisions down the road, not dissimilar to Johnson's deal and the question of customs and the Irish border. It seems likely that the first trade negotiation will be one of many.

The drama may be gone from the U.K. parliament after Johnson's thumping election victory, but trade negotiations will inevitably engage EU member states much more than the divorce talks. Wallonia, a region of Belgium, nearly scuppered the bloc's trade agreement with Canada, a risk neither Britain nor the EU wants to run this time.

White notes that member nations have often tacked on additions to trade deals in the past just so they can have a seat at the table or signing ceremony, although the European Court of Justice has taken a broad view of what the EU can negotiate on their behalf without requiring ratification by member states and regions. Ultimately, how quickly this can get done will be a political decision. "You can put an awful lot into an EU-only agreement," White adds.

Cooperation has always seemed a lot to ask when it comes to Brexit. Everything depends now on whether Johnson and Barnier can live up to their reputations for getting things done.

___

ABOUT THE WRITER

Therese Raphael writes editorials on European politics and economics for Bloomberg Opinion. She was editorial page editor of the Wall Street Journal Europe.

Visit Bloomberg News at www.bloomberg.com

0
0
0
0
0

Be the first to know

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

  • Updated

Picture a cool running stream - a ribbon of life in southern Arizona's rocky deserts. Now envision bulldozers stripping the surrounding land and erecting steel slats right across it. President Donald Trump wants to build part of his promised border wall on top of one of the last free-flowing rivers in the American Southwest. In late January, more than a thousand people gathered at an event ...

To retake the presidency in November, the Democrats will need to win the Electoral College. The clearest path to do that is to win the swing states that had the closest margins in the 2016 election. Fortunately, the Democrats have a playbook to follow from the 2018 midterm election. There are many factors that led to Democratic victories in the crucial swing states of Michigan, Minnesota and ...

By now, many are aware that our federal government ended last year with a deficit that surpassed $1 trillion and a national debt of more than $23 trillion. During his campaign for the presidency, President Donald Trump's inconsistent boasts about our fiscal affairs ranged all the way from asserting that he would "pay off the entire national debt" to calling himself "The King of Debt, " ...

  • Updated

Most of the media focus after a presidential primary naturally falls on who won, who did better than expected, who quit and whose candle is dangerously close to flickering out. But the most significant takeaway from Tuesday's Democratic primary in New Hampshire is just how much disarray the Democratic Party finds itself in. Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders' win is most notable for how little of the ...

  • Updated

After an unexpected December trip to China's Hunan province to bury her father, a Renton, Wash., woman returned home on Feb. 2. The following day, her husband told me, the woman was confronted at her door by her condo property manager. The manager told her because she had traveled to China, she should leave her home and be quarantined. On Feb. 4, flyers appeared in the entryway of her condo ...

At a candidate forum this past summer, the Poor People's Campaign, a national mobilization to amplify the voices of poor people, and the Institute for Policy Studies asked nine presidential candidates about their support for a series of ambitious programs, like a Green New Deal and universal health care. Generally, they supported them all. That's not surprising. Candidates promise lots of ...

  • Updated

Imagine for a moment that two people running a business together have a dispute over where to invest their funds, so they strike a compromise and write it into their contract. For two years, they agree, a little more than half of the money will go toward plant and equipment, and the rest toward labor costs. A few months later, however, one of them says they're borrowing too much, so he ...

As a consular officer, I issued hundreds of tourist visas to pregnant women traveling to the United States whose primary purpose was so-called birth tourism - gaining U.S. citizenship for their child by having their baby here. It was a frustrating experience for me, because I mainly saw wealthy and elite foreign nationals secure U.S. citizenship for their newborn this way, and I couldn't help ...

Is the Department of Justice under Attorney General William Barr facilitating Rudolph W. Giuliani's attempt to blacken the name of former Vice President Joe Biden? That's an understandable concern after Barr acknowledged this week that the department indeed was willing to evaluate information Giuliani had gathered from Ukrainian sources about Biden and his son, Hunter. In the July 25, 2019, ...

Baseball has been the background music of my life. Now, thanks to the Houston Astros and their sign-stealing cheat, I'm humming a different tune. I grew up in a Wisconsin town just big enough to have minor league baseball. The team name was the Indians, and nobody gave that a second thought. They were a Class-D Dodgers farm team; they played in a park a bike ride away, with a roof over the ...

Listen up!

Sign up for our Podcasts email!

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.

Topics

News Alerts

Badger Sports

Breaking News

Crime

Politics