Whether it’s made with muddled sugar cubes or simple syrup, 7-Up or Sprite, brandy or bourbon, the Old Fashioned is universally recognized as the unofficial cocktail of Wisconsin.
The Old Fashioned is one of the oldest cocktails in existence, and around here, one of the most popular. At the restaurant of the same name on the Capitol Square, manager Jennifer DeBolt estimates her bartenders make up to 400 Old Fashioneds on a given Saturday night.
“We’re celebrating everything Wisconsin here,” DeBolt said. “And nothing’s more Wisconsin than an Old Fashioned.”
In this country, the cocktail was first defined in 1806 as a combination of spirits, sugar, water and bitters. DeBolt has found archival versions made with lemon peel, cherries and with no added sugar.
These days, order an Old Fashioned at a local bar or supper club and you’re likely to get the sweet version: muddled maraschino cherry, orange and sugar, served with an ounce and a half of brandy and topped with 7-Up.
Variations are legion. Order an Old Fashioned “soda” to replace the 7-Up with seltzer, a “sour” to get one with sour mix, and a “press,” short for Presbyterian, to get a mix of seltzer and lemon-lime soda. Old Fashioneds made with bourbon or rye whiskey are common too.
Madison bars use a variety of techniques to distinguish their Old Fashioneds. Merchant offers the original recipe, with three dashes of bitters, one demerara (brown) sugar cube, 2 ounces of bourbon, rye or brandy, with orange and lemon oil on top. Quivey’s Grove uses Sierra Mist and a cinnamon stick.
Bartender Bob Perry has been making Old Fashioneds for more than 30 years at Smoky’s Club on the west side. He has made odd variations, like an Absolut Vodka Old Fashioned Press.
“It threw me,” he said. “I asked the waitstaff, are you sure that’s what they want?”
Perry said he grew up with the Old Fashioned as something “everybody drank,” sometimes too fast, because “because they’re so smooth and so good.”
“I don’t muddle them unless people want it. It gets way too sweet,” said Perry, who makes Smoky’s signature Old Fashioned with Woodford Reserve bourbon and Tuaca vanilla liqueur.
The Old Fashioned is “by far” the top seller at the Tornado Steak House downtown. Manager Bob Hemauer mostly gets orders for the brandy Old Fashioned — Wisconsin’s a brandy state.
“It’s traditional, it’s sweet,” Hemauer said. “Supper clubs and Old Fashioneds, why is it like that? It just is. … it’s like the Sazerac in New Orleans.
“I can’t explain its appeal,” he added. “It’s incredibly sweet, but to paraphrase H.L. Mencken, no one has ever gone broke underestimating the sugar-drinking capacity of the American public. A sweet drink is going to be popular.”
For the dedicated fan, the Old Fashioned downtown celebrates the cocktail once a year on the third Thursday in September, where for a brief window of time Old Fashioneds cost $1 each.
“We line them up behind the bar and everyone’s muddling,” DeBolt said. “We make 1,500 in three hours.”
Lindsay Christians occasionally pours tastings at Barriques.