Not since Brooks Bollinger replaced first-year starter Scott Kavanagh for the sixth game of the 1999 season has the University of Wisconsin football team made an in-season change at quarterback that wasn't dictated by injury.
Bollinger, a highly touted redshirt freshman back in 1999, replaced the injured Kavanagh at Ohio State and rallied UW to a 42-17 victory. Even though Kavanagh could have returned the next week against Minnesota, former coach Barry Alvarez went with Bollinger and never regretted it.
Indeed, knee-jerk reactions during the season haven't been the modus operandi at UW under Alvarez or current coach Bret Bielema. Not at quarterback. Not at many positions, for that matter.
Some think stability is especially important at quarterback. The Badgers had a quarterback derby during each of the last two training camps, but once Bielema named his starter, that was it. There was never a hint, at least publicly, of a potential change.
Given that history, it was quite a surprise Monday when Bielema said senior quarterback Allen Evridge would start Saturday's game against sixth-ranked Penn State but would be on a short leash if his performance didn't improve. In confirming that junior quarterback Dustin Sherer had been officially placed on stand-by, Bielema indicated that the coaches have grown tired of Evridge's inconsistency after only five games as a starter.
Bielema promised a review of many areas after UW lost its second straight game to drop to 3-2 on the season, but Evridge's lack of accuracy throwing the ball is a big reason the offense has underperformed since the competition got tougher in the last three games. It is not, however, the only reason, and Evridge shouldn't be made the scapegoat for UW's disappointing 0-2 start in the Big Ten Conference.
Young receivers have dropped passes. Tight ends Travis Beckum and Garrett Graham, the two most experienced pass-catchers on the team, have missed time because of injury. The line didn't pass-block as well against Michigan and Ohio State as it did in the first three games. And the running attack hasn't been as consistently productive as it was earlier, putting more pressure on Evridge to keep drives alive by throwing the ball.
Certainly, Evridge hasn't been as bad as some of UW's howling fans seem to think. Tyler Donovan, also a one-year starter, had a few rough moments last year, but Donovan's incredible toughness won over fans and muted some of the criticism he might otherwise have received.
Evridge has been extremely inconsistent, however. He has good size and a strong arm, but he's been guilty of holding the ball too long, hasn't made plays with his feet like Donovan did and, as Bielema pointed out, has missed open receivers with his passes.
Evridge might be able to iron out those problems in time. The problem is, with two Big Ten losses and red-hot Penn State coming to town, the Badgers are out of time.
If Evridge doesn't improve his level of play, Bielema needs to go to Plan B. And while he's at it, Bielema might want to put a few more people on short leashes this week. That includes players and coaches.